10 Comments
User's avatar
Mary Buchbinder's avatar

Yeah!! Joe, are you involved in creating those circumstances? Mary Buchbinder

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

I suspect if we have a sense of fairness and justice we, unavoidably, all are. The appeal inherent in my essay is that society, in my view, would be better off if people were not so quick to push the victimhood button, turn down the temperature a bit, and seek other ways of explaining and sharing an understanding of the injustices they endure.

Expand full comment
Jean Strickholm's avatar

This is a most thoughtful article on a complex subject.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

Many thanks, Jean. Complex it assuredly is.

Expand full comment
David Sprintzen's avatar

A fine effort to weave carefully among numerous potential minefields of misunderstanding, misinterpretation, and ideological advocacy.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

Many thanks. It is a difficult, nuanced topic that can generate strong feelings - perhaps often too much so!

Expand full comment
Waheed Khalid's avatar

Very good but please don't keep us waiting this long.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

Many thanks, Waheed. I have been writing these essays for a year now, at the rate of almost one a week. So far, the muse has been kind to me, but sometimes kinder than at other times. I am confident, though, that there will be more to come.

Expand full comment
Ed Gross's avatar

Because government policy is filled with trade-offs, it's always possible to be in a group that feels others are getting a better deal. Currently, the move to forgive student debt is a perfect example. Those who oppose it, rather than see it as help for the victims of a broken education and loan system, paint themselves as victims because they paid off loans and so aren't receiving the benefit. As you say in your excellent penultimate paragraph, it's all about seeing the larger picture and respecting our common humanity.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

Yes, student loan forgiveness is a most apt example of an issue that provides ammunition for feelings of victimhood by those who are not its beneficiaries. The examples, though, are endless. A point I imply is that some people may be just ready to cry victim, and then employ their cry as a political vehicle that leaves others suspect and resentful. A general lowering of the temperature across the board would be politically useful, as well as focus on issues that address the welfare of society as a whole,as you note.

Expand full comment