11 Comments
User's avatar
Jean Strickholm's avatar

Good analysis of complex issues.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

My thanks, Jean. Be well.

Expand full comment
Marvin Friedlander's avatar

Appreciate this insightful history of American evangelism. And school integration as a catalyst that energized evangelism in the south by stimulating private segregated schools makes sense. I wonder whether evangelists and right-wing politicians hooked onto each other to stimulate and ride an anti-abortion platform to riches and power.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

Certainly sounds plausible!

Expand full comment
Memories And Reflections's avatar

I have read other critiques similar to this. I was raised an evangelical and still hold to those ideas and ideals somewhat. I can assure you that conservative Christianity of the 1950s is nothing like today’s political movement disguising itself as a Christian. Power and lust for power do indeed corrupt. Thanks for this review.

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

You are most welcome. It is very good to have the perspective of an insider.

Expand full comment
Francesca Turchiano's avatar

Spot on. There’s a popular MAGA hat that reads “Jesus is My Savior, Trump is My President.” What an unsettling partnership!

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

Many thanks, Francesca. I think it is telling and important that Balmer, a lead authority from that very tradition, confirms that the Christian Right is not a religious entity, but a political movement. Indeed it is.

Expand full comment
Francesca Turchiano's avatar

Indeed! And a money-making enterprise, too.

Expand full comment
David Sprintzen's avatar

sounds right to me. but one should not completely underestimate the threat posed by the emergence of Darwinism in the late 19th century, leading to the creation of fundamentalism, particularly with the 1910 publication of The Fundamentals. .

Expand full comment
Joe Chuman's avatar

This is absolutely correct, though Randy doesn't address that dynamic in this book. In the 19th century, science had great prestige and theologians hitched their wagons to its authority. But Darwin went a step too far, and fundamentalism was assuredly a reaction to it.

Expand full comment